Skip to main content
Religion and Tolerance

The View From the East Pole: Buddhist and Confucian Tolerance

Publication ,  Chapter
Flanagan, O
2013

In this chapter I ask the question: Why are Buddhists and Confucians more tolerant, less conflict prone, less war-like, etc. than Abrahamic peoples IF THEY ARE?1 A proper analysis that positioned us to adequately answer this question would require defining the different concepts—“tolerance,” “conflict-prone,” “war-like”—producing evidence that it is true that there exist significant differences between adherents of these different traditions, and then using something like Mill’s methods to rule out political, economic, or material culture explanations of the differences, thereby making the reli- gious differences the most plausible candidate for the difference-maker.2 Here I do something less than what is needed. I operate on the assump- tion that it is true that Buddhists and Confucians are more tolerant, less conflict-prone, etc. than Abrahamic people, all else equal.3 Then I formulate a hypothesis for why the difference-maker may have to do with God, or better, with beliefs about God’s nature and modus operandi. I say “may” because I am not convinced that my hypothesis is true. The hypothesis is not that Buddhism and Confucianism are more rational, less superstitious than the Abrahamic religions. It is that Buddhism and Confucianism have theologies that differ from the Abrahamic ones in ways that make a difference. The core idea is that the belief in the Abrahamic God (Yahweh, God, Allah) engenders or supports attitudes and actions that demand epistemic and normative conformity across peoples with different customs, habits, and beliefs. Buddhist and Confucian theologies differ from each other in important ways, but share the following two features (Flanagan 2008; Flanagan 2011):

Duke Scholars

Publication Date

2013

Publisher

Oxford University Press
 

Citation

APA
Chicago
ICMJE
MLA
NLM
Flanagan, O. (2013). The View From the East Pole: Buddhist and Confucian Tolerance. In S. Clarke & R. Powell (Eds.), Religion and Tolerance. Oxford University Press.
Flanagan, O. “The View From the East Pole: Buddhist and Confucian Tolerance.” In Religion and Tolerance, edited by S. Clarke and R. Powell. Oxford University Press, 2013.
Flanagan O. The View From the East Pole: Buddhist and Confucian Tolerance. In: Clarke S, Powell R, editors. Religion and Tolerance. Oxford University Press; 2013.
Flanagan, O. “The View From the East Pole: Buddhist and Confucian Tolerance.” Religion and Tolerance, edited by S. Clarke and R. Powell, Oxford University Press, 2013.
Flanagan O. The View From the East Pole: Buddhist and Confucian Tolerance. In: Clarke S, Powell R, editors. Religion and Tolerance. Oxford University Press; 2013.

Publication Date

2013

Publisher

Oxford University Press