Text Recycling in Chemistry Research: The Need for Clear and Consistent Guidelines

Book Section (Chapter)

Like most scientists, chemists frequently have reason to reuse some materials from their own published articles in new ones, especially when producing a series of closely related papers. Text recycling, the reuse of material from one’s own works, has become a source of considerable confusion and frustration for researchers and editors alike. While text recycling does not pose the same level of ethical concern as matters such as data fabrication or plagiarism, it is much more common and complicated. Much of the confusion stems from a lack of clarity and consistency in publisher guidelines and publishing contracts. Matters are even more complicated when manuscripts are coauthored by researchers residing in different countries. This chapter demonstrates the nature of these problems through an analysis of a set of documents from a single publisher, the American Chemical Society (ACS). The ACS was chosen because it is a leading publisher of chemistry research and because its guidelines and publishing contracts address text recycling in unusual detail. The present analysis takes advantage of this detail to show both the importance of clear, thoughtfully designed text recycling policies and the problems that can arise when publishers fail to bring their various documents into close alignment.

Full Text

Duke Authors

Cited Authors

  • Moskovitz, C

Cited Editors

  • Schelble, SM; Elkins, K

Published Date

  • November 29, 2021

Book Title

  • International Ethics in Chemistry: Developing Common Values across Cultures

Chapter

  • 8

Published By

International Standard Book Number 13 (ISBN-13)

  • 9780841297982