Outcomes following treatment for ADA-deficient severe combined immunodeficiency: a report from the PIDTC.
(Clinical Trial;Journal Article)
Adenosine deaminase (ADA) deficiency causes ∼13% of cases of severe combined immune deficiency (SCID). Treatments include enzyme replacement therapy (ERT), hematopoietic cell transplant (HCT), and gene therapy (GT). We evaluated 131 patients with ADA-SCID diagnosed between 1982 and 2017 who were enrolled in the Primary Immune Deficiency Treatment Consortium SCID studies. Baseline clinical, immunologic, genetic characteristics, and treatment outcomes were analyzed. First definitive cellular therapy (FDCT) included 56 receiving HCT without preceding ERT (HCT); 31 HCT preceded by ERT (ERT-HCT); and 33 GT preceded by ERT (ERT-GT). Five-year event-free survival (EFS, alive, no need for further ERT or cellular therapy) was 49.5% (HCT), 73% (ERT-HCT), and 75.3% (ERT-GT; P < .01). Overall survival (OS) at 5 years after FDCT was 72.5% (HCT), 79.6% (ERT-HCT), and 100% (ERT-GT; P = .01). Five-year OS was superior for patients undergoing HCT at <3.5 months of age (91.6% vs 68% if ≥3.5 months, P = .02). Active infection at the time of HCT (regardless of ERT) decreased 5-year EFS (33.1% vs 68.2%, P < .01) and OS (64.7% vs 82.3%, P = .02). Five-year EFS (90.5%) and OS (100%) were best for matched sibling and matched family donors (MSD/MFD). For patients treated after the year 2000 and without active infection at the time of FDCT, no difference in 5-year EFS or OS was found between HCT using a variety of transplant approaches and ERT-GT. This suggests alternative donor HCT may be considered when MSD/MFD HCT and GT are not available, particularly when newborn screening identifies patients with ADA-SCID soon after birth and before the onset of infections. This trial was registered at www.clinicaltrials.gov as #NCT01186913 and #NCT01346150.
Cuvelier, GDE; Logan, BR; Prockop, SE; Buckley, RH; Kuo, CY; Griffith, LM; Liu, X; Yip, A; Hershfield, MS; Ayoub, PG; Moore, TB; Dorsey, MJ; O'Reilly, RJ; Kapoor, N; Pai, S-Y; Kapadia, M; Ebens, CL; Forbes Satter, LR; Burroughs, LM; Petrovic, A; Chellapandian, D; Heimall, J; Shyr, DC; Rayes, A; Bednarski, JJ; Chandra, S; Chandrakasan, S; Gillio, AP; Madden, L; Quigg, TC; Caywood, EH; Dávila Saldaña, BJ; DeSantes, K; Eissa, H; Goldman, FD; Rozmus, J; Shah, AJ; Vander Lugt, MT; Thakar, MS; Parrott, RE; Martinez, C; Leiding, JW; Torgerson, TR; Pulsipher, MA; Notarangelo, LD; Cowan, MJ; Dvorak, CC; Haddad, E; Puck, JM; Kohn, DB
Volume / Issue
Start / End Page
Pubmed Central ID
Electronic International Standard Serial Number (EISSN)
Digital Object Identifier (DOI)