Plasmonic nanostructures have attracted increasing interest in the fields of photochemistry and photocatalysis for their ability to enhance reactivity and tune reaction selectivity, a benefit of their strong interactions with light and their multiple energy decay mechanisms. Here we introduce the use of earth-abundant plasmonic aluminum nanoparticles as a promising renewable detoxifier of the sulfur mustard simulant 2-chloroethylethylsulfide through gas phase photodecomposition. Analysis of the decomposition products indicates that C-S bond breaking is facilitated under illumination, while C-Cl breaking and HCl elimination are favored under thermocatalytic (dark) conditions. This difference in reaction pathways illuminates the potential of plasmonic nanoparticles to tailor reaction selectivity toward less hazardous products in the detoxification of chemical warfare agents. Moreover, the photocatalytic activity of the Al nanoparticles can be regenerated almost completely after the reaction concludes through a simple surface treatment.