Contrasting responses to drought of forest floor CO₂ efflux in a loblolly pine plantation and a nearby oak-hickory forest


Journal Article

Forest floor CO2 efflux (F(ff)) depends on vegetation type, climate, and soil physical properties. We assessed the effects of biological factors on F(ff) by comparing a maturing pine plantation (PP) and a nearby mature Oak-Hickory-type hardwood forest (HW). F(ff) was measured continuously with soil chambers connected to an IRGA during 2001-2002. At both sites, F(ff) depended on soil temperature at 5 cm (T5) when soil was moist (soil moisture, θ>0.20 m3 m-3), and on both T5 and θ when soil was drier. A model (F(ff) (T5, θ)) explained > or = 92% of the variation in the daily mean F(ff) at both sites. Higher radiation reaching the ground during the leafless period, and a thinner litter layer because of faster decomposition, probably caused higher soil temperature at HW compared with PP. The annual F(ff) was estimated at 1330 and 1464 g C m-2 yr-1 for a year with mild drought (2001) at PP and HW, respectively, and 1231 and 1557 g C m-2 yr-1 for a year with severe drought (2002). In the wetter year, higher soil temperature and moisture at HW compared with PP compensated for the negative effect on F(ff) of the response to these variables resulting in similar annual F(ff) at both stands. In the drier year, however, the response to soil temperature and moisture was more similar at the two stands causing the difference in the state variables to impel a higher F(ff) at HW. A simple mass balance indicated that in the wetter year, C in the litter-soil system was at steady state at HW, and was accruing at PP. However, HW was probably losing C from the mineral soil during the severe drought year of 2002, while PP was accumulating C at a lower rate because of a loss of C from the litter layer. Such contrasting behavior of two forest types in close proximity might frustrate attempts to estimate regional carbon (C) fluxes and net C exchange.

Full Text

Duke Authors

Cited Authors

  • Palmroth, S; Maier, CA; McCarthy, HR; Oishi, AC; Kim, HS; Johnsen, KH; Katul, GG; Oren, R

Published Date

  • March 2005

Published In

Volume / Issue

  • 11 / 3

Start / End Page

  • 421 - 434

Pubmed Central ID

  • AGR:IND43722720

International Standard Serial Number (ISSN)

  • 1354-1013

Digital Object Identifier (DOI)

  • 10.1111/j.1365-2486.2005.00915.x


  • eng