Skip to main content
Elsevier BV

Q Group Research Proposal: Private Equity Risk and Return: Recent Evidence

Preprints
Sensoy, BA; Robinson, DT
2009

Although of paramount importance to limited partners (LPs) in private equity funds, measuring the risk and return of private equity investments has proven a daunting challenge for empirical research. A key constraint has been lack of data: information on the timing and size of cash flows into and out of private equity funds is not publicly available. Moreover, the limited data that has been used in prior studies extends no later than 2003 and tends to focus on funds raised before 1993 (e.g. Phalippou and Gottschalg, 2008). Therefore, estimates from prior studies may bear little resemblance to the recent experience of investors in private equity funds, given the huge increase in fundraising dollars in recent years and, of course, the extreme liquidity dislocations caused by the financial crisis of 2007-2009. To address this important gap in knowledge, we have obtained a confidential and proprietary dataset containing precisely dated, detailed information on the cash flows into and out of every private equity fund in which a large LP has ever invested. The data begin in the early 1980s and continue through the second quarter of 2009, and contain over 1500 private equity funds, spanning the buyout, venture capital, and real estate sectors. The recency, depth and breadth of the data allow us to investigate the impact of the current financial crisis on the private equity markets. To our knowledge, ours is the largest and most recent dataset of private equity cash flows ever made available for research. Moreover, the cash flow data are disaggregated into management fees, capital calls (investment capital called by the fund), and distributions (cash flows from liquidations of underlying fund investments). This allows us to separately study the determinants of capital calls and distributions in the industry, and has the potential for important new insights given that most previous research has been limited to studying net cash flows. With these data, we will investigate in detail the performance of private equity funds from the early 1980s to the present, with particular attention to more recent periods for which estimates of private equity performance based on cash flows do not exist. Our analysis will place considerable emphasis on the impact of the current financial crisis, which caused an unprecedented dislocation in liquidity, on the performance of private equity funds. We will also relate fund performance to fund characteristics such as investment types, size, and past performance. We will also investigate the risk attributes of private equity funds from the LP perspective. One institutional feature that sharply differentiates private equity from other investment vehicles, such as public equities, is that LPs commit in advance to provide a certain amount of capital to the private equity fund (committed capital) over the course of its life (typically 10-12 years). The timing of the actual capital calls (when the capital is actually provided to the fund) is at the discretion of the fund manager, not the LP. Thus, and as the current crisis has amply demonstrated, a key risk of investments in private equity funds (particularly leveraged buyout funds) is that larger capital calls will occur precisely when the expected return of investment in fund portfolio companies is high but the private equity fund itself is least able to raise debt financing for the investment and thus require relatively more equity capital. The risk of these capital calls arises from the fact that these are also the times in which LPs themselves are most likely to be the liquidity constrained, and may for example have to liquidate investments in liquid securities at fire-sale prices in order to meet the capital call. Our study will quantify this risk and more generally explore how private equity fund capital calls and distributions co-vary with macroeconomic and market-wide factors, in both normal and crisis times. The extant literature offers little to no evidence on these issues. Our results will considerably enhance the profession’s understanding of the risk and return properties of private equity both as an asset class an in the cross-section, and particularly in recent times. Therefore, the results should be of enormous practical importance to institutional investors who are or are considering becoming investors in private equity.

Duke Scholars

Altmetric Attention Stats
Dimensions Citation Stats

DOI

Publication Date

2009
 

Citation

APA
Chicago
ICMJE
MLA
NLM
Sensoy, B. A., & Robinson, D. T. (2009). Q Group Research Proposal: Private Equity Risk and Return: Recent Evidence. Elsevier BV. https://doi.org/10.2139/ssrn.1455993
Sensoy, Berk A., and David T. Robinson. “Q Group Research Proposal: Private Equity Risk and Return: Recent Evidence.” Elsevier BV, 2009. https://doi.org/10.2139/ssrn.1455993.
Sensoy, Berk A., and David T. Robinson. “Q Group Research Proposal: Private Equity Risk and Return: Recent Evidence.” Elsevier BV, 2009. Crossref, doi:10.2139/ssrn.1455993.

DOI

Publication Date

2009