Lead isotopes and rare earth elements geochemistry of global phosphate rocks: Insights into depositional conditions and environmental tracing

Phosphate rock bears both geologically and environmentally significant information. Rare earth elements and yttrium (i.e., REY) characteristics have been commonly used for reconstructing the redox conditions of depositional environments and the effects of post-depositional diagenetic alteration on phosphate rock. In addition, phosphate rock is typically enriched in a range of trace elements such as uranium (U) and cadium (Cd) that can be dispersed as contaminants into the environment with phosphate mining and phosphate fertilizer application. Here we report the lead (Pb) isotope compositions combined with Pb and REY concentrations of both global sedimentary and igneous phosphate rocks, aiming to evalute the geological origin of phosphate rocks over time and the potential of using them for environmental tracing. Phopshate rock samples analyzed in this study were sourced from major economic phosphate deposits in the world, including China, Southern Tethys (e.g., Morocco, Tunisia, Israel), the U.S., India, South Africa and Russia. Our results show a wide range of 208Pb/204Pb (35.70 to 60.58), 207Pb/204Pb (15.20 to 18.25), and 206Pb/204Pb (16.369 to 71.806) ratios in the phosphate rocks, with sedimentary phosphate rocks being significantly more radiogenic than igneous rocks. The majority of sedimentray phosphate rocks show a notable isotopic overprinting by non-radiogenic terrestrial Pb, except for those from Israel and Morocco that have the most radiogenic Pb isotope compositions. Correspondingly, phosphate rocks with more radiogenic Pb isotope ratios show relatively pristine seawater REY features, likely suggesting their preservation of the original oxic seawater conditions and/or minimal diagenetic alteration. In contrast, phosphate rocks with less radiogenic Pb isotope compositions show REY indications for more anoxic seawater redox conditions and/or greater diagenetic alteration. We further evaluate the potential utility of Pb isotopes for tracing the associated contamination with phosphate rock mining and fertilizer application in the environment. In most cases, the radiogenic Pb isotope composition of phosphate rocks and corresponding P-fertilizers is distinctive from both natural crustal Pb and major anthropogenic Pb sources (e.g., Pb ore deposits and pesticides), which provides a great advantage for applying Pb isotopes as an environmental tracer for metal(loid) contamination from phosphate sources. The combination of Pb isotope ratios and REY proxies could further constrain the Pb source discrimination. Overall, this study provides new Pb isotopic and REY geochemical data on global phosphate rocks and fertilizers, which lays the groundwork for future regional and local studies on both their geological and environmental implications.

Duke Scholars

Author Gordon Williams  

Author Robert Hill  

Author Avner Vengosh Earth and Climate Sciences