Comparing ambient scribes: a randomized crossover clinical trial addressing ambient scribe technologies' impact on physician burnout.

OBJECTIVE: This study aims to compare the effectiveness of 2 ambient AI scribe technologies in reducing physician burnout, improving workflow satisfaction, and enhancing documentation efficiency through a randomized crossover trial. MATERIALS AND METHODS: An open-label randomized crossover trial involving 160 outpatient clinicians was conducted at a tertiary academic medical center. Volunteers were randomized to 2 groups of 80 with 2 crossover periods. We assessed workflow satisfaction (1-7 scale), burnout (Copenhagen Burnout Index), and efficiency metrics (eg, electronic health record time outside scheduled hours, documentation time, etc.). Data was analyzed using Wilcoxon signed-rank tests and generalized linear mixed models. RESULTS: Surveys from 136 respondents were analyzed. Clinicians reported greater improvements in satisfaction with product B (2.51 points on a 7-point scale) compared to product A (1.91 points; mean difference: 0.60, 95% CI: 0.32-0.90). Both tools reduced personal and work burnout scores, but differences between tools were not meaningful. Product B demonstrated greater reductions in average minutes-in-notes per day compared to product A (B - A = -3.19 minutes; 95% CI -4.87 to -1.50). No meaningful differences were observed in pajama time or patient-related burnout. DISCUSSION: Both tools improved workflow satisfaction and reduced burnout, with product B showing superior performance in satisfaction and documentation time. However, efficiency metrics like pajama time were largely unaffected, potentially due to participant selection bias and the study period's timing. CONCLUSION: Product B yielded greater satisfaction and time savings compared to product A, though both tools effectively reduced physician burnout and improved workflow satisfaction.

Duke Scholars

Author Benjamin Alan Goldstein Biostatistics & Bioinformatics, Division of Translational Bi ...

Author Eric Gon-Chee Poon Medicine, General Internal Medicine

Author Kathryn IIonka Pollak Population Health Sciences

Author Armando Diego Bedoya Medicine, Pulmonary, Allergy, and Critical Care Medicine

Author Jonathan Wilson  

Author Ananda Chowdhury Medicine, Pulmonary, Allergy, and Critical Care Medicine