Convergence and divergence of B cell responses in two HIV-1 Env immunizations in Rhesus macaques.
BACKGROUND: Sequential multivalent immunizations are used to counter diversity in rapidly mutating viruses. Here, we evaluated the effect of HIV-1 immunogen formats on the binding profile of memory B-cells elicited in two independent Rhesus macaque trials. METHODS: In one trial, female Rhesus macaques were immunized with a multiclade HIV-1 gp120 envelope glycoprotein (Env) cocktail and bled two weeks post final immunization. In another trial, male and female Rhesus macaques were sequentially immunized with clonally-related Env glycoproteins: Four immunogens were administered as non-stabilized gp140 Envs and the fifth as a specially stabilized gp140 Env trimer (SOSIP); animals were bled before and after SOSIP immunization. Immunogen-binding peripheral memory B-cells were sorted and cultured at limiting dilution. Culture supernatants were assessed by ELISA for binding to individual immunogens. RESULTS: In the first trial, 81% (591/734) of B-cells cross-react with multiple Envs and most bind to all immunogens. In the second trial, 81% (331/410) of B-cells isolated before SOSIP administration react with all non-stabilized gp140 Env immunogens and 27% also cross-react with the yet-to-be-administered SOSIP-stabilized Env. However, after SOSIP administration, SOSIP-stabilized trimer-reactive B-cells increase to 86% (219/256) but most (82%) do not cross-react with the preceding immunogens. CONCLUSIONS: Multiclade and sequential regimens before SOSIP-stabilized Env immunization elicited B-cells that converge on shared epitopes. A change in immunogen format results in a divergent B-cell response that vastly fails to engage prior responses. Critically, B-cell priming with non-stabilized Env cannot modify the effect of the epitope immunodominance hierarchy in a SOSIP trimer. These results suggest that a change in immunogen format may cause off-target B-cell engagement, but also that B-cell repriming is possible despite pre-existing immunity.
